The court record you have is certainly about the Shenandoah Valley Shulers (i.e., Orange, later Augusta, later Rockingham, later Page County VA). George Shuler, only son of John Shuler, grandson of (John) Mathias Shuler had a number of sisters who stayed and raised families in and around the Shuler homesteads.
George Shuler (b. 1794) married Talitha (Tabitha/Elitha...) Dovel in 1814 in Rockingham Co. Her father David is present and presents surety. George builds up the farm in VA, and appears on every census roll there until he dies in the 1873. Probably not the same George.
I don't know how these folks (& this George b.1794) may have been related to the Pennsylvania, Maryland, or North Carolina Shulers. There were at least three Shuler families in PA in the 1730's who may be in line with George (b. 1792), and a large Shuler clan was emerging in NC about this same time. If you learn of their connection, please send word.