Goodmorning, I am a descendant of several of the Vineyard families, namely CATHCART.Robert Gershom CATHCART is my 7th great grandfather.I have read a wonderful transcription on the web of 'The History of Martha's Vineyard by Dr Charles Banks' Volume III Family Genealogies: pp 69-71 and pp 20-27 ( as well as several other pages).I am a little confused as per The Cathcart Family "1. Robert CATHCART m Phebe COLEMAN abt 1691 dau. ofJohn and Joanna (FOLGER) COLEMAN of Nantucket who was b 15 June 1674."andThe Athearn Family "10.Samuel ..... m 16 Sept 1719 Mrs Phoebe (COLEMAN) CATHCART (wid. of Robert CATHCART) (1) and dau of John and Phoebe (STARBUCK) COLEMAN of Nantucket, who d bef 24 Nov 1739."I am confused as to who Phoebe COLEMAN'S parents were.I do have a COLEMAN & STARBUCK connection in my family tree program but the John COLEMAN I have b 2 Aug 1667 m Priscilla STARBUCK 1694 b 1676 d 1762.I know that a lot of the 'island' mariages were intertwined and am hoping that you may be able to help me to decipher my riddle.Thank you so very much for your time.
Casandra Colegrove-Borland Oswego County, New York, USA