Found Edward in 1850 in West Virginia Ohio County Pg 197 with wife Mary Ann, mother Elizabeth age 45 from Ireland and daughter Elisabeth age 17 born PA. In the 1860 census for some reason Edward and Mary are not togetherHe age 31 living in Ohio County. In 1870 census Mary age 44 is in Ohio County. Living with her are 3 daughters Emma, Kate and Elisabeth. The last is not the same Elisabeth from the 1850 census but a younger one born 1866 in Virginia. By the 1880 Census He and Mary are back together still in Ohio County with Emma living with them.