I realize it has been quite a while since you posted this. You may very well have solved your mystery on your own! If not, here is the info I have as this is in my Stine family notes.... William D. Stine (12/9/1827-8/11/1885) m. Rebecca D. Stout (1/15/1834-4/21/1917), 12/5/1852, Pickaway Co., OH children: Sarah C. Stine (~1853-?) m. Eugene B. Crowell (7/18/1851-5/2/1922) Isaac Franklin Stine (3/7/1860-5/19/1950) m. Salome Elizabeth Bender (9/7/1869-12/10/1953) Lovina Enora Stine (1/31/1865-6/14/1958) m. Sardis Sherman Crowell (12/12/1864-1/14/1914)
The William Stine family was found living in Sandusky Twp., Sandusky Co., OH during the 1860, 1870 and 1880 census. It is in the 1880 census that the family was reduced to William, Rebecca, "Franklin", Lavina, and Catharine Stout (Rebecca's mother).