I have a death certificate on Martha Jane (Pence) Love. Her parents are listed as Samuel Pence & Catherine Stoner. Her married name was Love so I am assuming this is not her. 1860 Census of Mahoning Twp., Lawrence County, OH shows a James and Catherine in the household of Samuel & Catherine as well.
I do have the name of Anna Maria Pence in my ged com database as their daughter as well but do not remember the source. She is listed as born Jan 14, 1827 Scott Twp, Lawrence Co., PA and died Mar 12, 1892 Edinburg, MahoningTwp, Lawrence Co., Ohio.
I hope this may be of some help to you or to others that may come across this information.