Sarah Ann McDonald b.30 Nov 1840 d.26 Jan 1925 married Bartholomew Tarpey 24 Feb 1873 in Lancaster. Perhaps he is related to Charles, Patrick, and Thomas Tarpey. Here's what I have on them and I suspect they are from County Mayo:
1. Thomas O'Regan Tarpey b.15 Oct1834 Ireland d.12Dec1894 Lancaster,OH married on 12 Dec 1894 in Lancaster Mary A. Morris b.Jan 1842 Charlestown,Mayo Ire d.27 May 1919 Lancaster, OH. Mary is my great,great,great grandmother's sister. I have her obituary with some of these details.
Thomas and Mary had: John 1870-1870 Thomas Frank 1871-1911 James Edward 1872-1932 Patrick Henry 1875-1932 m. Mary Tarpey cousins? Mary Ellen 1878-1940 m. Thomas Guy Sullivan 1880-1945 George Vinson 1881-1946
2. Charles Tarpey b. abt 1837 d.?? married to Anna ? they had:
Kate 1868 John 1870 Mary 1874 Maggie 1879
3. Patrick b. abt 1850 d.??? lives with Thomas Tarpey who is the head of household in 1880 Census along with John Morris b-in-law and niece Mary Gallagher Tarpey.
They live next door to John Franey who is Mary Morris's uncle, who is also from Mayo, Ireland.