I have since found yet anothre transcription ostensibly for the same list---this one is in Summers, 1903.
None of the three lists match well.Each has people not found in one or the other of the documents.Each excludes persons found in one or another of the other documents.
I take it you are probably working from a transcription of the original (e.g., in Rev. Cummings biography, etc.)Which probably means there's yet a fourth version of this list.
With regard to the question about the Totten-Teeters relationships---I'm afraid I can add nothing here.My only connection to the Teeters is that George happens to be on that Ebbing Springs Call to Charles Cummings.While I'll eventually have some information about him (simply because he's on that list) I've nothing at the moment.But hopefully some bone fide Teetors researchers will have something to say.