Well, found a conection to the Tharp,and Headley fams.
Source: Original data: Fretz, A. J.. A genealogical record of the descendants of Leonard Headley of Elizabethtown, N.J. : together with historical and biographical sketches and illustrated with portraits and other illustrations. Milton N.J.: Joseph W. Headley, 1905.
Rob. Headley b. Conn Farms, Union Co NJ, in 1720, d. Milton NJ. Apr, 28, 1806,
Mary, m. Michael Stagg,will, Oct. 18, 1757
m. Sec. Phebe [Baldwin] Gardner,
Jos, 1758,d. 1842, m. Martha Riker. b. Sussex, NJ, 1758, d.1842 [There is a Riker/Thorp m.]
*Wil, Oct 23, 1767 d. Aug 22, 1856, m. Sarah Strait, dau of Jacob and Abi. Gould Strait
Phebe,m. Peter Smith to Licking Co OH.
family to Wyoming Valley PA.,Indian troubles....
July 2, 1778 wife and sons Jos, Sam, Wil, Phebe, back to Hopewell mountain, Sussex Co., spring of 1779 to Milton Morris Co NJ. ["Sussex Reg" mentions William Headley and the massacre.]
Seems likely, this is the William named in the deeds.
"Newspaper clippings from the Sussex register"
1838 May 8, Wil D. Headley opens business at Andover
1849 Sept. 1, Sarah, wife of Wm Headly, Milton, 71
1856, Aug. 22, Wil Headly, Milton, Morris Co. nearly, 87
Note below, Eliz. name, Bountain? I didn't find any, would you make a guess?
Sam D Headley b. abt, *1765 d, ? m. Elizabeth Bountain, b. Morris Co NJ Aug 21, 1775 d.? Lived at Milton NJ. on farm now owned by Ed R Headley and which Sam Headley prob. heired from his father Robert. Late in life rem. from Morris Co., NJ, to Seneca Lake, in Yates Co NY where they died, Blacksmith and farmer, Freewill Bap.
ELECTRA HEADLEY, b. Jan. 26, 1797 d.? m. NATHANIEL HOPPING,[Hopper?] b. May 15, 1792, d? Kept Hotel at Milton. m. Morris Co NJ, Dec. 22, 1814, [Moses Hoppen in the forge business]
Elizabeth Hopping, b. Jan. 22, 1819 d. ? m. Eleazer M. THORP, PO Chariton, Iowa. Farmer and Pettifogger,
C. *Moses, Nathaniel,Marie, Electa, Josie, etc.
1850 Moses, b. NJ., to OH to IN., dau. Malinda, b. 1834, IN., Eleazer THorp and fam, plus Thomas C Stewart, and Phil...Thorp, are all neighbors, in, Piatt, Sangamon Co IL.
The Stewarts and Eleazers Thorps fam. go to IA.
There is much more...inc.Headley/Gardner marr. had son Ben Gardner, m. Mary Thompson,
son,Jacob Thompson Gardner m.Sarah Miller,
Nancy Cooper Gardner, b, Dec 25, 1806, d. July 15, 1876, m. Henry W. Thorp, June, 26, 1823,
1850Indiana Clinton Owen
Henry W. Thorp, 57, NJ farmer
Nancy, 47 NJ
Henry W, 20, NJ,1830
Phebe, 18, OH 1832
Jane, 16, OH
Jacob, 12, OH
Theodore, 6, OH, 1844
One tree has Nancy d. in IL., and who does Henry belong to?
Maybe someone else will add to this.