Hi Marilyn, I can give you my best educated guess on William Thistle and Mary's family.
William Thistle and Ann of Mulley's Cove.
Children of: 1. Elizabeth Thistle: bapt.1816 no Date 2. Jane Thistle: bapt. 29 Nov. 1818 3. William Thistle: bapt. 3 Mar.1822 4. Julia Thistle: bapt. 17 Sep.1826 5. William Thistle: bapt. 14 Dec. 1828 ****your William 6. George Thistle: bapt. 1 Aug. 1830 7. Susan Thistle: Born. 10 Aug. 1835
William Thistle of Mulley's Cove married Mary King of Mulley's Cove 26 Dec.1849 P-52 Vol. Panl 52 B wit: Joseph King and Edward King.
Children of: 1.Noah Thistle: b. 29 Feb 1852 Mulley's Cove. 2.Matthew Thistle b. 25 Jul.1855 Mulley's Cove. 3.Thomas Reuban Thistle: b. 1 Dec.1857 Mulley's Cove 4.Allen Thistle: b. 5 Feb. 1864 Mulley's Cove.
Note: Broad Cove United Church Cemetery: Matthew Thistle b.1855 died 1939. Spouse Sarah.
Note Noah Thistle: Died 29 Jul.1925 Paper Date St. John Daily News. Noah Thistle: Died 1925 Bay of Roberts Guardian News paper.
Noah Thistle of Mulley's Cove married Elizabeth Tucker of Burnt Point 4 Dec. 1883 Wit: Matthew Thistle & Thomas Tucker P 125-4 Panl Vol 52-B
Children of: 1.Mary Ann Thistle: b.16 Oct. 1888
Matthew Thistle of Mulley's Cove married Sarah LeGrow of Broad Cove. 17 Nov. 1882 Wit: Mark LeGrow & William LeGrow Blackhaed Meth Marr Panl Vol 52-B
Children of: 1.Allen Penny Thistle:b.11 Jul.1884 2.Hayward Thistle: b. 12 Sep.1886 3.George Allen Thistle:b. 21 Sep.1888 4.Hannanh Beatrice Thistle: b. 30 Jan. 1892 Died 24 Jun.1892 Blackhead Meth Birth & Baptisms.
Note Baxter of Harbour Grace Died age 21 31 May 1929 son of Henry Thistle
This may be The family of William Thistle and Mary. Let me know your Thoughts... Kind Regards . Gary Thistle.....