HI Robin, Don't know if you have any other info yet but I might have a few bits to help your search. From what I found, WIlliam and Phebe, daughter of Joseph Smith Tichenor and Caroline Ward, are both buried in Rosedale Cemetery in Orange, NJ. 1880 census list Edgar working in a shoe shop in East Orange, NJ. Also listed are wife, Phebe, daughters, Sarah C.,22, and Maggie L.,10, and sons, William S,16, and James H., 14.1900 census list him as living in East Orange, Ward 2, being 72 years old. Also list his year of immigration as 1850. And living in the household are James,34, and Margaret, 30. Hope this helps.