Hi Suzi, I have Zebulan Timms born 1854 in Stanbridge,BDF to Samuel Timms & Mary Ann RicKard (dates as yours), ancestry as yours etc.....and potentially of interest to you back to the mid-1600s.
Sam -- as you may imagine from the naming of his son was an active minister in the Baptist church (Zebulan was one of the sons of Jacob and Leah (Genesis 29,30; Ruth 4,11)
NB in the1891 Census index this comes out as "Levnlun"
I have Zeb's marriage to Mary Hornden and then 8 children of that marriage, although your Caleb is born 1879 not 1859 as you state. Sadly, at this time I haven't followed through on these offspring, but for sure we are some kind of cousins.
Maybe you'd like to contact me directly at email@example.com