Yes, I've seen that one, thank you. Benjamin & Harold were my mother's half brothers. We knew Harold well, but Mom barely knew Benjamin, he grew up with his Mother & rarely (to our knowledge) had anything to do with their Dad. The Fay Rippy listed with Benjamin in the 1930 census has me intrigued, because Ben & Harold's mother was Lula Fay (Tucker) Rippy. Mom never knew anything about ahalf sister, but the census suggests that Fay was.