Thank you for your reply.My grandmother, Margaret Mae, Maggie, Peggy Tully was born 10/14/1877 in Franklin, Columbus, Ohio to John Peter Tully and Flora Cummings.John's father Patrick came from Ireland, mother's name was Julia, last name unk. Their eldest daughter, Marie, Mary, was born in New York in 1854,and son Patrick T was born in 1852 in NY. John Peter, my ggrandfather was born in Ohio in 1859. I have located all of the children except John Peter and his parents. And I don't know if Patrick T and his wife Margaret, Maggie had children.