Tuttle/Tuthill Lines in America indicates this Samuel Tuthill was born at Orange County, NY 9 May 1789, the son of Jeremiah Tuthill, who was born in 4 Dec 1754 at Ulster County, NY. Jeremiah Tuthill married 17 May 1799; Anna, b. 6 Jun 1758, Brookhaven, Long Island, daughter of Ebenezer & Jeremiah (Tooker) Hulse. She died at Penn Yan, New York, 11 Mar 1846. Census records suggest Samuel Tuthill lived in Blooming Grove, NY; Florida, NY; and Cuyahoga Falls, Ohio. His wife was Maria, dau. of Asa & Elizabeth Bailey, who was born at Warwick, NY, c1797. Maria and Samuel married at Orange County, New York on 9 Dec 1815.