Thanks, Lisa, but it is a different Eve.It looks like the Eve Umbaugh who married Adonirum J.Serles was the daughter of George Umbaugh & Catherine Summers.She was born 1834 in Wayne County, Ohio and died in Iowa.
George & Catherine's daughter Lydia, b. 1847 in Wayne County, Ohio is the one who married William Warhurst.
The Mary Umbaugh who married William A. Dusten is another daughter of George & Catherine.She was born 1832 in Wayne County, Ohio.
I suspect the Jacob and Catherine Umbaugh listed in your message are two of Jonas Umbaugh and Sarah Harting's children.George & Jonas were brothers.Jonas also had a daughter named Mary, and she is probably one of the other Marys you mentioned, but I'm not sure which one.
Thanks for your help.Even though it didn't answer our question about Eve (Simons) Umbaugh, it certainly did give me some leads to followup on for the other Umbaughs you listed!Eve (Simons) Umbaugh, by the way, was the mother of George and Jonas Umbaugh.Don't you love all those repeated names?