Hi Jean, Thanks for your response. I would surely love to figure this mystery out. I have yet to visit the cemeteries, but have seen the list of names on internment.net. I don't think I've seen any records of Rinear jr. though. It may be him. Please contact me off the board at firstname.lastname@example.org. I do have quite a bit of the line from then on, from a few ancestry.com family trees posted. Would you have any info. on a Peter Van Sickle that married Eleanor Fonger in Jerseyville?This was one of my possibilities as well, as a first marriage.