We may have a match here. Jacob Elmer Witchey, born 1863, d 1964 was my great gandfather. I saw this page and called my parents who confirmed that my great-gandfather was indeed married to Hattie Dill. Some other names I recognized were Mary Lou Witchey, my aunt and Holt. Jacob's grandaughter Pauline Witchey was married to Clifford Holt. I know the name Witchey is Swiss (Bernese) in origin. Thank you for the post!