Karen: Yes, that helps a lot.I have just recently learned that Staley wasn't my Eliza's middle name, but that she was married to Wm. Staley, so that at the time she married my John Clabaugh in 1847, her name was Elizabeth Whitehearst Staley, not Elizabeth Staley Whitehearst.
I have run across Toliver lots of times, but my source gave Eliza's father as S.H. Whitehearst, so I thought that Toliver must be a cousin.I will pursue this new line and hope to nail these folks down soon.Are you of this line?
Thanks for taking the time to help me out.Happy New Year to you and yours. Sandy