Don, would the older children have gone to live on farms in the area?I have a Susan and a Sandy Wine (male) living with William Carruthers and his wife in Loudoun Co in 1850. Ann Wine (could be the Margaret Ann who married Benjamin Griffith??)is living with the Laycock family in Loudoun in 1850.Susan appears in Muskinghum in 1860 with the family of Joel White, another Loudoun transplant.She married Dan Hunter and died in Muskingum in 1910.Their older brother William married Emily Carruthers and moved to Muskingum Co, OH.Where did you get your information??I've been looking for William's parents, obviously unsuccessfully, for years. I only got onto him when I foudn his obituary, naming his sister Mrs. Susan Hunter of Washingtonn Twp.I had suspected she was related but couldn't find anything.Her death cert lists "Geo Wine" as her father.One of William's daughters lists her father's birth palce as "Stafford Co, VA."