There seems to be much controversy over the wives of Wm. Witcher Sr. I do not have the answer. So I am as confused as you! I show Wm. Sr. married Liddy Atkinson in 1750, possibly in Ca. and then a marriage in 1762 to Mary Majors. If this is right that would mean that Wm. Jr. was born before his father married Mary Majors. So his mother was maybe Liddy Atkinson??I dunno!!
I have Wm. Sr.'s son Caleb, born 1760 married Geody, (it was spelled Giddy in my paper), Watson on Dec. 10, 1799.
William Witcher Jr., born 1754 married Polly or Molly Dalton April 1, 1782, also had a son named Caleb who married Fanny James.
That is the info I have..right or wrong... and there is a lot of room to be wrong! It really can be confusing. If I didn't help I hope I didn't hurt. lol