I am not researching this family, just happen to have this piece of information on a sheet which was sent to my by a distant relative.This was from the records of Prudence Groff Michael, a well-known genealogist in Indiana:
"Page 59 of 'Early Lutheran Baptisms & Marriages in Sougheastern Pa. Records of Rev. John Casper Stoever' gives Jan. 14, 1743 as the date he married John Pontius & Anna Catarina Zoeller, at Tulpehocken. (which at that date was in Lancaster Co., Pa.)Their first child, John Henrich, was born there Feb. 24, 1744. (p. 26, above book).
In the Pontius Forum the wife's last name is listed as Zeller.