Hello again Alan, Saw this posting and thought I would give you what info I had on these ones. I have a Jane Zufelt born: 1841, if arrested for these charges would of been 37 at the time. She was married to one Harry Rightmeyer. I have no further info on them except that Janes father is Alpheus Zufelt in Canada, mother is Susan Wilkins.
Also I have a Emily Zufelt married to Abraham Prince. Emily is the daughter of Henry Young Zufelt and Ophelia Hogaboom.
This is the only information that I had on these listings on your posting. May have Daniel Zufelt, will have to look him up later.