| Name | Birth date | Relationship with John Sr. |
|---|---|---|
| Metcalf, Alonzo Buford | 1877 | 4th great-grandson |
| Metcalf, Amelia | 1780 | Great-granddaughter |
| Metcalf, Andrew K. | 1808 | 2nd great-grandson |
| Metcalf, Anthony | 1735 | Grandson |
| Metcalf, Archie Green | January 02, 1916 | 5th great-grandson |
| Metcalf, Ashley Cawthorn | July 05, 1834 | 3rd great-grandson |
| Metcalf, Barbara Esther | April 28, 1938 | 6th great-granddaughter |
| Metcalf, Bascom Clement | March 17, 1927 | 6th great-grandson |
| Metcalf, Baxley | 1865 | 4th great-grandson |
| Metcalf, Betty Faye | October 25, 1939 | 6th great-granddaughter |
| Metcalf, Brenda Joyce | 7th great-granddaughter | |
| Metcalf, Cameron Anthony | 7th great-grandson | |
| Metcalf, Carolyn | 7th great-granddaughter | |
| Metcalf, Caseson Parker | February 06, 2002 | 8th great-grandson |
| Metcalf, Cathrine (Cathy) | March 02, 1952 | 6th great-granddaughter |
| Metcalf, Charles Cawthorn | December 05, 1901 | 5th great-grandson |
| Metcalf, Colton Brice | July 22, 2000 | 8th great-grandson |
| Metcalf, Daniel Janson | July 02, 1992 | 8th great-grandson |
| Metcalf, Danza | 1759 | Great-grandson |
| Metcalf, Dena Kaye | 7th great-granddaughter | |
| Metcalf, Dewight Allem | March 10, 1951 | 6th great-grandson |
| Metcalf, Diane | February 14, 1944 | 6th great-granddaughter |
| Metcalf, Donald | 7th great-grandson | |
| Metcalf, Elizabeth | March 04, 1781 | Great-granddaughter |
| Metcalf, Elizabeth | 1784 | Great-granddaughter |
| Metcalf, Elizabeth Betsy | June 25, 1794 | 2nd great-granddaughter |
| Metcalf, Elizabeth Jean | July 28, 1928 | 6th great-granddaughter |
| Metcalf, Eula Florence | September 13, 1898 | 5th great-granddaughter |
| Metcalf, Foster Clayton | January 11, 1908 | 5th great-grandson |
| Metcalf, Gayle | December 31, 1941 | 6th great-granddaughter |
| Metcalf, George | 1731 | Grandson |
| Metcalf, Grace | July 08, 1783 | Great-granddaughter |
| Metcalf, Henry A. | 1866 | 4th great-grandson |
| Metcalf, Henry J. | January 09, 1823 | 3rd great-grandson |
| Metcalf, Isaac | 1757 | Great-granddaughter |
| Metcalf, Isaac | February 06, 1779 | Great-grandson |
| Metcalf, Isaac | 1798 | 2nd great-grandson |
| Metcalf, Isabella | 1790 | 2nd great-granddaughter |
| Metcalf, Jacob | 8th great-grandson | |
| Metcalf, Jacob | February 23, 1789 | Great-grandson |
| Metcalf, Jacqueline (Jackie) | November 14, 1939 | 6th great-granddaughter |
| Metcalf, Jake Brent | April 22, 1972 | 7th great-grandson |
| Metcalf, James | November 19, 1746 | Grandson |
| Metcalf, James | August 06, 1771 | Great-grandson |
| Metcalf, James | November 1825 | 3rd great-grandson |
| Metcalf, James Douglas (Doug) | 1942 | 6th great-grandson |
| Metcalf, James Frankiln | 1854 | 4th great-grandson |
| Metcalf, James G | 1868 | 4th great-grandson |
| Metcalf, James Lamar | December 28, 1940 | 6th great-grandson |
| Metcalf, Jamie | 7th great-granddaughter |