| Name | Birth date | Death date |
|---|---|---|
| Chloe Foster | Unknown | |
| Chris Fletcher Slinger | January 08, 1886 | Unknown |
| Christena Clouse | September 17, 1827 | |
| Christina | Unknown | |
| Christina Croskey | February 1804 | 1888 |
| Christine | Private | |
| Christopher Comer | 1755 | 1820 |
| Christopher Eden Comer | Private | |
| Clara Allyn Wheeler | 1869 | Unknown |
| Clara May Healy | March 19, 1859 | Unknown |
| Clarence Loveland Healy | September 15, 1859 | Unknown |
| Clarissa Healy | December 06, 1798 | Unknown |
| Clement Corbin | 1626 | August 01, 1696 |
| Clifton Dwight Healy | January 21, 1848 | Unknown |
| Clifton Ketchum | 1877 | Unknown |
| Cornelia Sousley | Bef. 1754 | 1805 |
| Cornelis Barentsen Slegt | Abt. 1616 | November 05, 1697 |
| Cornelis Garretse Van Nieuwkerke | 1658 | February 07, 1694/95 |
| Cornelis Hoogeboom | Unknown | |
| Cornelis Van Nieuwkirk | August 30, 1696 | August 17, 1774 |
| Cornelius Newkirk | August 12, 1716 | 1765 |
| Cornelius Nieuwkirk | September 02, 1733 | November 08, 1795 |
| Crowe | Unknown | |
| Cudworth | Unknown | |
| Curtis Metcalf | Private | |
| Cynthia Marie Comer | Private | |
| Cyrus Newkirk | May 27, 1800 | Unknown |
| Cyrus Newkirk | May 05, 1799 | November 17, 1850 |
| Daisy Wheeler | March 1896 | Unknown |
| Daniel Allen Cone | Private | |
| Daniel Comer | 1766 | Unknown |
| Daniel Comstock | Unknown | |
| Daniel Cryder | Unknown | |
| Daniel Dwight Healy | December 26, 1818 | July 20, 1832 |
| Daniel Healy | January 15, 1850 | Unknown |
| Daniel Lincoln Pratt | June 24, 1820 | November 02, 1902 |
| Daniel Lyon Healy | December 26, 1792 | May 14, 1850 |
| Daniel Lyon, Jr. | Unknown | |
| Daniel Marcy | June 14, 1738 | Unknown |
| Daniel Marcy | April 27, 1765 | May 14, 1833 |
| Daniel Wheeler | 1720 | Unknown |
| Darrel Baylor | Private | |
| David C. Wildermuth | April 06, 1890 | |
| David Comer | 1839 | Unknown |
| David Comer | Abt. 1788 | Unknown |
| David Craigie | Private | |
| David Culp | Unknown | |
| David Culp Kolb | Unknown | |
| David House | July 01, 1789 | May 14, 1872 |
| David Kidder | June 28, 1740 | Abt. 1772 |