| Name | Birth date | Death date |
|---|---|---|
| Matthew William Davies | Private | |
| Matthys Cornelius Slecht | 1649 | 1709 |
| Mattys Ten Eyck | Unknown | |
| Maurine Steckman | May 03, 1901 | Unknown |
| Megan Jean Comer | Private | |
| Mehitabel Marcy | August 17, 1744 | June 11, 1781 |
| Mehitabel Mayo | Unknown | |
| Melba Comer Brookshire | September 20, 1897 | Unknown |
| Melvin Metcalf | Private | |
| Melvin S. Dodds | Unknown | |
| Meribah Perry | June 11, 1695 | Unknown |
| Merritt House | Abt. 1811 | January 15, 1883 |
| Merritt House, Jr. | June 1843 | April 06, 1916 |
| Mert A. Ketchum | 1875 | Unknown |
| Mesheck Remington | 1731 | February 04, 1757 |
| Michael Comer | 1758 | August 13, 1822 |
| Michael Comer | Abt. 1787 | Unknown |
| Michael Jeffrey Bros | Private | |
| Michael Sarnicki | Private | |
| Mildred Edith House | February 25, 1874 | Unknown |
| Miles Ives | Unknown | |
| Miller | Private | |
| Millie F. Comer | November 12, 1882 | Unknown |
| Millie Frances Smith | Abt. 1860 | September 27, 1883 |
| Miriam Comer | Private | |
| Miriam Hoffman | June 05, 1904 | November 26, 1990 |
| Miriam Marcy | November 20, 1742 | March 19, 1812 |
| Missouri Newkirk | October 17, 1809 | November 26, 1856 |
| Moses Marcy | July 02, 1730 | Unknown |
| Moses Marcy | April 18, 1702 | October 09, 1777 |
| Muriel Metcalf | Private | |
| Myers | Unknown | |
| Myra Amelia Wheeler | September 16, 1867 | September 13, 1935 |
| Myra Jane Winchester | Private | |
| Myrtle Maria Bigsby | March 10, 1884 | Unknown |
| Nancy Agnew | January 1823 | March 31, 1909 |
| Nancy Ann Michaels | 1807 | Unknown |
| Nancy Carolyn Whiting | Private | |
| Nancy Rae | Unknown | |
| Naomi Comer | November 22, 1820 | Unknown |
| Nathan Crosby | February 09, 1674/75 | Unknown |
| Nathan Pratt | Unknown | |
| Nathaniel Corbin | September 29, 1758 | Unknown |
| Nathaniel Healy | February 19, 1760 | Unknown |
| Nathaniel Healy | September 03, 1736 | October 05, 1817 |
| Nathaniel Healy | September 28, 1686 | July 01, 1706 |
| Nathaniel Healy | February 06, 1658/59 | June 02, 1734 |
| Nathaniel Kidder | August 29, 1746 | December 09, 1756 |
| Nathaniel Kidder | February 27, 1658/59 | Unknown |
| Nathaniel Kidder | May 02, 1765 | Unknown |