| Name | Birth date | Death date |
|---|---|---|
| Nathaniel Perry | July 02, 1713 | Unknown |
| Nathaniel Price | Unknown | |
| Neeltje Gerritse Van Nieuwkerke | 1667 | 1706 |
| Neil E. Comer | December 27, 1880 | April 24, 1887 |
| Nellie Maria Comer | June 07, 1875 | August 19, 1875 |
| Nellie May Healy | August 18, 1862 | Unknown |
| Nelson Evans | 1847 | Unknown |
| Nicholas Babbs | Abt. 1525 | Unknown |
| Nicholas Buttrice | Unknown | |
| Nicholas Camp | Unknown | |
| Nicholas Peck | Unknown | |
| Nicholas Sarnicki | Private | |
| Niobe D. | Private | |
| Norris Nelson Comer | Private | |
| Obadiah Wheeler | 1718 | Unknown |
| Obadiah Wheeler | Abt. 1506 | Unknown |
| Obadiah Wheeler | October 27, 1671 | |
| Olive Lovina Irons | February 14, 1868 | Unknown |
| Olivia Newkirk | October 20, 1820 | December 17, 1900 |
| Ormel Eli Wheeler | April 02, 1833 | February 10, 1915 |
| Orphena B. Comer | Unknown | |
| Orval Amos | 1906 | Unknown |
| Orval M. Ketchum | 1865 | Unknown |
| Orville Harold Gatz | Private | |
| Owen F. Dodds | Unknown | |
| P.H. Newkirk | 1827 | Unknown |
| Parker Willard | June 26, 1788 | Unknown |
| Patty Porterfield | Unknown | |
| Paul Healy | April 03, 1664 | Unknown |
| Paula Comer | Private | |
| Peggy Rae | Unknown | |
| Penelope Brosard | Abt. 1722 | Unknown |
| Perley Healy | August 30, 1769 | September 25, 1775 |
| Perley Healy | July 26, 1776 | Unknown |
| Permelia Newkirk | December 23, 1805 | July 05, 1833 |
| Peter Bolenbaugh | March 06, 1816 | March 06, 1887 |
| Peter Brackett | Bet. 1580 - 1585 | August 1616 |
| Peter Brackett | Unknown | |
| Peter Crispel | 1664 | 1695 |
| Peter DuBois | Unknown | |
| Peter Hay | 1788 | October 27, 1852 |
| Peter Hay | Unknown | |
| Peter Lamb | Unknown | |
| Peter Newkirk | 1728 | 1804 |
| Petronella Slecht | 1652 | April 28, 1689 |
| Phebe Green | Abt. 1667 | |
| Philip Comer | Abt. 1758 | 1824 |
| Philip Comer | 1770 | 1820 |
| Philip Lamb | Abt. 1779 | August 04, 1832 |
| Philip Perry | Abt. 1743 | Unknown |