| Name | Birth date | Death date |
|---|---|---|
| Sidney Metcalf | Private | |
| Simon Crosby | Abt. 1609 | September 1639 |
| Simon Crosby, Jr. | August 06, 1637 | January 22, 1725/26 |
| Sissie Newkirk Comer | February 11, 1869 | November 30, 1870 |
| Solomon DuBois | Unknown | |
| Sophia Davis | Unknown | |
| Sophia Healy | July 29, 1783 | Unknown |
| Sophia Newkirk | 1761 | Unknown |
| Sophronia Taylor | July 25, 1847 | January 14, 1930 |
| Stanberry Newkirk | 1850 | Unknown |
| Steckman | Unknown | |
| Stephanie Lynn Comer | Private | |
| Stephen Corbin | August 05, 1760 | Unknown |
| Stephen Healy | August 23, 1762 | March 24, 1838 |
| Stephen Kidder | November 26, 1662 | Unknown |
| Stephen Lee | Unknown | |
| Stephen William Davies | Private | |
| Steve Guenther | Private | |
| Steven Michael Comer | Private | |
| Stillborn | September 20, 1874 | September 20, 1874 |
| Susan Vincent | Abt. 1560 | Unknown |
| Susan W. | 1883 | Unknown |
| Susanna Catherine Seitz | 1690 | Unknown |
| Susanna Hagar | Abt. 1655 | Unknown |
| Susanna Newkirk | 1838 | Unknown |
| Susannah Hay | July 06, 1781 | July 04, 1841 |
| Susannah Jane Comer | April 14, 1839 | Unknown |
| Susannah Newkirk | February 18, 1807 | February 18, 1830 |
| Susannah Perry | December 27, 1701 | Unknown |
| Susannah Wheeler | March 31, 1607 | March 24, 1648/49 |
| Suzanna Newkirk | 1840 | Unknown |
| Suzanne Comer | Private | |
| Teracea Elise Comer | Private | |
| Teunis Eliasen Van Buntschooten | Abt. 1655 | Unknown |
| Thankful | Unknown | |
| Theunis Newkirk | July 13, 1718 | August 01, 1769 |
| Thomas A. Blower, Jr. | Abt. April 23, 1587 | Abt. 1639 |
| Thomas Agnew | Unknown | |
| Thomas Bingham | May 21, 1576 | March 1631/32 |
| Thomas Bingley | 1556 | WFT Est. 1586-1647 |
| Thomas Blower | Abt. October 1597 | |
| Thomas Buckminster | Unknown | |
| Thomas Crosby | 1575 | May 16, 1661 |
| Thomas Crosby | 1635 | Unknown |
| Thomas Dodds | February 15, 1800 | January 1866 |
| Thomas Kidder | August 21, 1750 | Unknown |
| Thomas Kidder | August 03, 1700 | January 08, 1791 |
| Thomas Kidder | March 01, 1656/57 | Unknown |
| Thomas Newkirk | 1844 | Unknown |
| Thomas Sayre | 1474 | Unknown |