| Name | Relationship with Samuel Carpenter | Civil | Canon |
|---|
| Passage, Harry C. | Husband of the 5th great-granddaughter | | |
| Passage, Janet | 6th great-granddaughter | VIII | 8 |
| Passage, Marie | 6th great-granddaughter | VIII | 8 |
| Paul, Sydney | Wife of the 3rd great-grandson | | |
| Pemberton, Hannah | 2nd great-granddaughter | IV | 4 |
| Pemberton, James | Husband of the great-granddaughter | | |
| Pemberton, James | 2nd great-grandson | IV | 4 |
| Pemberton, Mary | 2nd great-granddaughter | IV | 4 |
| Pemberton, Phineas | 2nd great-grandson | IV | 4 |
| Pemberton, Rachel | 2nd great-granddaughter | IV | 4 |
| Pemberton, Ralph | Husband of the 6th great-granddaughter | | |
| Pemberton, Rebecca Clifford | Wife of the 5th great-grandson | | |
| Pemberton, Sarah | 2nd great-granddaughter | IV | 4 |
| Penington, Frances Lewis | Wife of the 3rd great-grandson | | |
| Penington, Josephine L. | Wife of the 3rd great-grandson | | |
| Penington, Mary M. | Wife of the 3rd great-grandson | | |
| Pepper, Adeline Louise Forbes | 6th great-granddaughter | VIII | 8 |
| Pepper, Charlotte Eleanor | 6th great-granddaughter | VIII | 8 |
| Pepper, Frances | 5th great-granddaughter | VII | 7 |
| Pepper, George | Husband of the 4th great-granddaughter | | |
| Pepper, George Wharton | 5th great-grandson | VII | 7 |
| Pepper, George Wharton Jr. | 6th great-grandson | VIII | 8 |
| Pepper, William | 5th great-grandson | VII | 7 |
| Peters, Evelyn Willing | Wife of the 4th great-grandson | | |
| Pettit, Matilda | Wife of the 4th great-grandson | | |
| Pickman, Fanny | Wife of the 4th great-grandson | | |
| Pleasants, Samuel | Husband of the 3rd great-granddaughter | | |
| Plummer, Bessy Allison | 5th great-granddaughter | VII | 7 |
| Plummer, David Allison | 5th great-grandson | VII | 7 |
| Plummer, Isabella Campbell | 5th great-granddaughter | VII | 7 |
| Plummer, John | Husband of the 4th great-granddaughter | | |
| Plummer, John | 5th great-grandson | VII | 7 |
| Plunkett, Francis Richard | Husband of the 4th great-granddaughter | | |
| Plunkett, Helen | 5th great-granddaughter | VII | 7 |
| Plunkett, Norah | 5th great-granddaughter | VII | 7 |
| Poey, del Monte y | Husband of the 4th great-granddaughter | | |
| Poor, John Caldwell | Husband of the 4th great-granddaughter | | |
| Poor, Wharton | 5th great-grandson | VII | 7 |
| Post, Arthur | Husband of the 4th great-granddaughter | | |
| Post, Helen Agnes | 5th great-granddaughter | VII | 7 |
| Powel, Annie Hare | 6th great-granddaughter | VIII | 8 |
| Powel, John Hare | 5th great-grandson | VII | 7 |
| Powel, John Hare Jr. | Husband of the 4th great-granddaughter | | |
| Powel, Pemberton Hare | 5th great-grandson | VII | 7 |
| Preston, Hannah | Daughter-in-law | | |
| Pumpelly, Delphine Marie | Wife of the 4th great-grandson | | |
| Pyecroft, Arthur | Husband of the 5th great-granddaughter | | |
| Rawle, Margaret | Wife of the great-grandson | | |
| Raymond, Lois Mather | Wife of the 5th great-grandson | | |
| Read, Edward | 3rd great-grandson | V | 5 |
