| Name | Birth date | Death date |
|---|---|---|
| Pauley, Martha | 1847 | Unknown |
| Pauley, Martha | 1847 | Unknown |
| Pauley, Mary A. | 1865 | Unknown |
| Pauley, Mary Ann | 1846 | 1896 |
| Pauley, Mary Ann | 1845 | Unknown |
| Pauley, Nancy | 1851 | Unknown |
| Pauley, Nancy J. | 1862 | Unknown |
| Pauley, Preston | 1823 | October 25, 1854 |
| Pauley, Preston | 1843 | Unknown |
| Pauley, Preston | 1856 | Unknown |
| Pauley, Rufus | 1842 | Unknown |
| Pauley, Samuel | Abt. 1790 | Unknown |
| Pauley, Squire | 1812 | 1893 |
| Pauley, Squire | 1844 | Unknown |
| Pauley, Washington | 1840 | Unknown |
| Pauley, William | 1843 | 1918 |
| Paxton, ??? | Unknown | |
| Payne, Amy | 1790 | Unknown |
| Payne, Harry | 1793 | Unknown |
| Payne, Levi | Unknown | Unknown |
| Payne, Nehemiah | 1795 | Unknown |
| Payne, Phoebe | January 30, 1840 | December 26, 1923 |
| Payne, Susanna | 1798 | Unknown |
| Peacock, Mary | 1818 | |
| Pearce, Living | Private | |
| Pearce, Living | Private | |
| Pearce, Living | Private | |
| Pearson, ? | Unknown | Unknown |
| Pearson, Francis | Unknown | Unknown |
| Pearson, Mary | Unknown | Unknown |
| Pearson, Thomas | Unknown | Unknown |
| Peer, Living | Private | |
| Peer, Living | Private | |
| Peer, Living | Private | |
| Peer, Living | Private | |
| Pegg, Emma | Unknown | Unknown |
| Pegg, Rebecca | Unknown | Unknown |
| Peirpoint, Edmond De Pue | Private | |
| Peirpoint, Haymond | Private | |
| Pelley, Lester | Private | |
| Pensa, Domenicantonio | Unknown | Unknown |
| Pensa, Mariana Nicola | Abt. 1742 | July 06, 1803 |
| Pepper, ??? | Private | |
| Pepper, Elizabeth | Abt. 1815 | January 23, 1890 |
| Perkins, Creed | Abt. 1850 | Unknown |
| Perkins, Harry | Bet. 1876 and 1877 | Unknown |
| Perrault, Olive | Unknown | |
| Perrine, Macel E. | Private | |
| Perry, Classie | Unknown | |
| Perry, Florence | Abt. 1792 | Unknown |