I'm a bit behind with this!Just now read the data you posted regarding the family of Edward Monarch, who was my great-grandfather--no kidding! I am from a long line of second marriages, and thus, older fathers.John was not Edward's son, but his nephew, and I think the son of James, Edward's older brother. Eliza, the eldest child of Edward and his first wife,Eleanor Beaven,was born in 1818, and by the 1850 census was married to Benedict Mattingly. There was also a son named George W(illiam?)Edward's second wife was Mary Frances (Wheatley) LeHigh, whose LeHigh children, found living in this household, were James LeHigh, not "Leigh", and Elizabeth. By his marriage to Frances Wheatley,Edward was the father of Sarah (her Baptismal records call her Susan), middle name Genevieve, who was dead by the 1860 census, as well as Benjamin, the Civil War Cavalryman, Samuel Isadore, Juliana Frances, John Edward (my grandfather), and Melissa Jane.