St. Matthaeus German Evangelical Church Records

This is a long shot, but here goes. I found out that my ancestors marriage record is located in the church books for St. Matthaeus - married July 13, 1869. I found this information on the Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints site - it gave me a film number and the college where the film rolls are. I contacted the Cincinnati Library as well as the college. Both places told me the same. There are many books for the church... and books 2-5 are missing, which include marriages, births, etc. from 1856/57 - 1880. Does anyone know where these books might be located? Thanks!