There's a slight possibility this is your John with second younger wife(?)Note, sons James and John show mother born in KY, while younger children show MS, which would match birth location of Julia.The only thing, this shows John b SC and further down you'll see Napoleon and Lafayette show father born in GA.Of course, it also shows them the same age and they do not show up as twins on the 1850 census.You didn't include John's wife when you listed those in his household for the 1850 census, and I thought she was already dead.She is listed as Naturly in 1850.
Categories: Name; Relationship to head of household; Marital Status; Gender; Race; Age; Birthplace; Occupation; Father's Birthplace; Mother's Birthplace.
John CARGILESelfMMaleW65SCFarmingVAVA Julia CARGILEWifeMFemaleW43MSHouse KeepingSCVA James H. CARGILESonSMaleW23TXAt Work On The FarmSCKY John M. CARGILESonSMaleW20TXAt Work On The FarmSCKY Lewis M. CARGILESonSMaleW2TXSCMS CARGILESonSMaleW2MTXSCMS William MASSEYOtherSMaleW31MSHired HandSCSC
From Wise Co, TX 1880 census:
Napoleon CARGILLSelfMMaleW32TXCity MarshallGAGA Sally CARGILLWifeMFemaleW34PAKeeps HousePAPA Eva KNIGHTSDauSFemaleW16TXKeeps HouseTNPA William KNIGHTSSonSMaleW13TXAt SchoolTNPA Walter CARGILLSonSMaleW6TXTXPA Richard CARGILLSonSMaleW4TXTXPA Eugene CARGILLSonSMaleW2TXTXPA Pearl CARGILLDauSFemaleW7MTXTXPA Harry STEWARTNephewSMaleW12TXAt SchoolTXPA
From 1880 census Brazos Co, TX:
L. CARGILLSelfMMaleW32TXFarmerGAGA Martha A. CARGILLWifeMFemaleW30LAKeeping HouseALGA Lou Ellen CARGILLDauSFemaleW8LATXLA Jos. P. CARGILLSonSMaleW6LATXLA Fred B. CARGILLSonSMaleW2TXTXLA
Have you had a chance to check out other census records for John and Natalie?Maybe you can see if they stayed in Panola Co, TX, or moved on.
I would post queries on the GenWeb counties for all of the counties where your Cargills resided.Because it is less common maybe someone will recognize the family.Also, ask in your query if anyone has a county history and would they check their copy for any possible information on the Cargill family.
Looks like quite a few Cargills stayed in Brazos Co, TX.There are 13 listed in that county on TX Dth Idx 1964-1998.