I am not related but found some info on Preston from his death cert. The information was provided by Virginia Nutter, whose address was the same as that of the deceased, who probably was his daughter.
Preston was born in Clarksburg, WV the s/o Christopher and Marie Pugh NUTTER. Both parents were born in Virginia.
Preston died 26 Jan 1936 in SLC, UT, about 83 years old. He was a white male, married, wife was Katherine Fenton NUTTER. He was a cattleman for 43 years. The cause of death was myocarditis and he was buried in the Salt Lake Memorial Mausoleum on 29 Jan 1936.
The 1930 SLC census shows Preston 70, wife Catherine F. 59 and daughters, Katherine M. 19 and Virginia F. 17.
If Preston was aka James, he may have been in Murphy, Ritchie, WV in the 1880 census.
A Christopher NUTTER and Mariah PUGH married on 23 May 1839 in Harrison Co. VA.