Jim, My working papers reflect James Abercrombie 1843(son of James Abercrombie 1808) died in 1871.I failed to record a source for the info. Is his death year 1871?
In the 1880 census Chambers Co. AL i found James Abercromby and Martha listed in Beat 4 page234 entry 319/320. James is listed as 70 years old and Martha is 45 years old. No children are listed. Where is Charlie Frank Abercrombie and Mattie Abercrombie found in the 1880 census?
Sorry i can not provide any info on the female Abercrombies from the first marriage of James and Sara.