Has the argument of who is the father of Benj been settled? From what I've seen I would have to say that Benj is son of John not Sam. Samuel and Benj are living in diff households not the same according to the census. Samuel was married in 1832 from what I've found and Benj would have been born around 1826. The only thing that makes me wonder is the gap between children of 1806 to 1825 with James. Who are the children in between if Benj and Samuel are brothers?