Hi, I research APPLEGARTH but I have not been able to connect this family as yet. This is what I believe in brief are the connections. Phoebe Cosell married John Coulson, their children:William c1855, John c1859, Emily c1860 and Elizabeth c1862. Phoebe then married William Applegarth in Qtr. 3 1860 Guisbrough. Their children:Henry c1866, William c1880, Robert c1883 and Emily Harriet c1895. Henry c1866 married Harriet Bulmer, their 1st of five children was Willy Reuben Applegarth 11 May 1890. I do not have too much detail on this line but many others do I am sure. Hope this helps.