Thankyou for your message regarding Jacob Paddon Argent and his daughter, Caroline. From the information you provided it does look like we are related to Jacob. The only bit of information that i have which is different is that Caroline was born in Halstead. I do have her husband, Samson/Sampson Butcher, as being born in Bocking.
I have tried to send you an e-mail but you have kept your e-mail address 'hidden'. If you go back to my original message, click on my name, it will show you my e-mail address. This is still valid. Send me an e-mail and we can compare details and help fill in others.