I have been researching families in Fayette Ohio with several fifth cousins for about 10 years. While researching Beard / Baird I took another look at this small family cemetery on find a grave:
Archer, Jamimah 75823254 b. unknown d. Jul. 1, 1853 Archer Cemetery Fayette County Ohio, USA
Archer, John 75822892 b. unknown d. Apr., 1838 Archer Cemetery Fayette County Ohio, USA
There are also several Hoppes in this cemetery and I had to revisit the Hoppes. There was a Jacob Caylor who married a Catherine Atcher. They were both from Loudoun, VA. Catherine was a daughter of Peter Oatyer of Loudoun and the name is sometimes spelled Atcher by descendents. Jacob and Catherine Atcher Caylor's daughter Sarah married John Hoppes. It is believed that Peter Oatyer came from New Jersey and there are no Oatyers in New Jersey, but a lot of Archers there.