Today I found the answer to who Sarah wife of Wiley Woodall is in the Estate notes for Abraham Atchley's will.She is in fact another one of his daughters.
Sarah Ann Atchley b. Oct 17, 1826m. Wiley Woodall
Wiley Woodall was from Jackson, AL where Abraham Atchley was found in the census in 1830 and 1840.In the 1830-1840 census it does makes sense that she is his daughter by the count of female daughters and ages to what family members we have listed.Not to mention she is listed in the Estate notes.
I have placed her in the 1850, 1860, 1870, 1880, and 1900 censuses.She spent the majority of her life in Calhoun County, where another source listed her husband Wiley Woodall was pastor of an Oak Grove Church there.
This leaves us with the question...was Sarah Elizabeth born in 1849 Abraham's daughter?Or was she Eliza Ann Atchley's daughter who has been rumored to have married a Konkle man, and we see her living with Sarah throughout her life.