Herbert Atherton is my 2nd cousin, twice removed. He, his wife Carrie (who I have last name Hawk) and a son Arthur Lee Atherton all share a single tombstone in the cemetery in Philadelphia, IN (the one where Little Orphant Annie is buried). I was told by another cousin that those 3 all died about the same time of a flu epidemic. I didn't know of any other children, but would love to have your info on that. Herman Atherton was Herbert's twin (buried same cemetery). Our common ancester is Charles Atherton, the man who platted the town of Philadelphia, IN (but buried in Greenfield, a few miles east). I'd be delighted to share other info. Email me.