I show sons Joseph B. Atherton and Milton Atherton, along with other siblings (no birth dates) born to John McDougal Atherton. John was b. 1841, d. 1932, wife was Marie Beeler, John's father was Peter Atherton. I do not know if this Joseph and Milton were twins, but they are listed together, and children are usually listed in birth order, if so these are the oldest. My information says current Atherton's near Mt. Sherman, KY, are descendents of this Peter Atherton. Would like to share information on descendents and ancestors.