Does Charlotte and or son appear in the MD. 1840/1850 census' to show that they still live in the area- and show where they were born? (1850)Does Andr.Jackson Baldwin live until the 1880 to show Mother bn. -Father bn. ... ?Surely Eliza Baldwin/Hoffman would have know that her mother & father were not born in NY if she is indeed the dau. of Rezin & Charlotte.Or the census taker made a mistake, (since husband Hoffman Wilsey was from NY and his parents) Perhaps some day the puzzle pieces will fit... but for now I can only presume that there are two Eliza Baldwins born approx. the same time...But.. there are those "Charlotte" names in both lines... Hmmmm! ?Thanks for the info.. let me know if you find anything interesting.