My name is Leona Ralph. My husband George Ralph has a first cousin, Marian Baldwin. She married George Baldwin, a son of Edward Baldwin, who was a son of Patrick Baldwin that you mentioned in your post. I will be glad to share what I know about the Baldwin family. I too am interested in knowing a little more about Patrick Baldwin and Margaret Thistle. They moved from Newfoundland to Lake Forest Ill about 1892 I believe. I know very little about anything in Newfoundland or before.