Goodness, you found an OLD posting of mine. Your thoughts are on target, though. My Baldwins did come from Tompkins Co. about 1823 (and before that Greene Co, NY, and earlier from Litchfield Co., CT). I found a Townsend on my tree but not until the 1900s -- and on another branch. Lorena Streeter also appeared but not until the 1900s. Thanks for taking time to send me a message and Happy Hunting.