According to my records, Charles Anderson Bartle(30 Oct 1795, near Oxford, Chenango Co., NY - 13 Jan 1875, Scott Co., IN), a s/o Hendrick (= Henry) Bartle, m. Hulda Gray(13 Nov 1798, near Oxford - 09 Sep 1843, IN), d/o Jeduthan Gray and Ruth Loomis, moved from NY to Indiana TWICE, in 1819/20 and 1836/8.They had ten ch. One was a dau. Elizette (02 Aug 1824, IN - 1872, Scott Co., IN) who m1 Albert Hartley with whom ahe had two ch, then m2 Aaron Hubbard (perhaps William H. Hubbird), about whom I have no information. (That name is not unlike the one you mentioned). Charles and Hulda also had son John Henry (Miller) Bartle (02 May 1827, IN - 20 Dec 1858, IN) who m(13 Jan 1847, Scott Co., IN) Phoebe Richey, d/o Dr. John Richey and Sichey Collings.My records state that she had two sons by a preceding marriage, namely Simeon Richey and George Washington Richey(1841 - c. 1910) who m1 Nancy --- and had ch. Perry Lewis Richey, Rozella Mehaley Richey, and Seth Thomas Richey.John and Phoebe had at least 5 ch. of their own, whose names I have -- one was John Loomis Bartle (1852 - 1914).But no John W.'s here. One might ask why, if Phoebe was d/o Dr. John Richey and had been prev. married (presumably to a man not named Richey), were her sons were named Richey?Various scenarios come to mind, but I don't know the answer.