It is quite likely that the Henry Harrison Black who married Lucinda Tolman in about 1857 appears in the 1880 United States Census for Owen County, Indiana.This census shows a Henry Black (b. ~1842 in Indiana) married to a Lucinda (b. ~1844 in Indiana) with three of their children living with them, i.e., John W. Black (b. ~1865), Effie Black (b. ~1871) and Cora D. Black (b. ~1873).These three children may be the siblings of James Benjamin you have been looking for.This Henry Black states that he was a farmer and his parents were born in Pennsylvania.Lucinda states that her father was born in Vermont and mother in Virginia.It appears that all of Henry's children born prior to 1865 were no longer living at home.Hopefully this is your Henry Black and that the above information is something you had not previously found.