Thanks for your help. I know quite a bit about Calvin once he got to Kentucky. His wife's name was Dora. Their son, Edgar, was my grandfather. Dora lived to be fairly old and my father knew her. We just don't know anything about Calvin's life prior to his arrival in Kentucky including who his parents are. My cousin, Vernon Waldrip, found some information from someone on the Internet years ago that lead him to believe that Calvin's parents were David and Susan. I spoke with Vernon shortly before he died and he said that he was never able to prove that. When I saw Cornelius and Phebe listed in the Census also, I was suspicious that they could have been his parents. I don't know that I will ever be able to prove either one because as you pointed out the 1890 Census was destroyed. Maybe someday I will get to Saline County and try to do some further digging.