Are you still intersted in Lucy Marshall? I think I've identified her, but am still searching for proof. She was probably not born in Shutesbury. On her marriage records she is said to be from Amherst. I suspect she is a daughter of Peter Marshal and Sarah Davis who had 7 children in Dudley before moving to the Amherst/Leverett area.Two other children of Peter marry in Shutesbury. WIll share more on my theory.