All I have is 1850 Census Eaton Co. Michigan info say: Downey or Donny C. Brundage, 34, Farmer born in NY Wife Elvira ,23 ,born in NY Alphis or Alphonso A., 7 ,born in NY Emeline ,6 ,born in NY VanRenselaer, 4, born NY William ,1, born in NY Also living with this family were Electra Turnball ,18, born NY and Sally Conkling ,12, born NY Through other sources I found that Van Renselaer married Mary Amidon while William married Minerva Amidon (the mother of Mary Amidon) Emeline married a Mr. Nodell and they had a daughter named Ida Nodell In 1870 Domeny C. or Downey Brundage lived in Benzie Co., Michigan In 1880 they were also in Benzie Co. In 1880 D.C. Brundage had his wife and children Dora and Orren G. and Granddaughter Ida Nodell , age 6 ,born in Mich.,were living with DC. Elvira aka Alvira had the maiden name of Trumball.(She was born Dec 5, 1893)(Note Electra Turnball living with them so probably it was eitherTurnball or Trumball, probably sisters) Orren G. Brundage married Lillian Kentner. Orren died Jul 1927 Dora was Adora Alvira Brundage and she married James F. Masters. D.C. Brundage's birthdate was Jun 12 1896 Since the census doesn't show a daughter Catherine I can't help you more than this. Hope this helps.