First, where was your Creech family located? What state?
Unless you know where William H. was in 1880, possibly coming from Canada, this looks like a fellow you could check out if you haven't already done so: 1880 Stark Co., OH - William H. Creech, p:403A Canton Ward 3. The census at least will show whatever he gave as his birth place; you will have to determine it's accuracy. If it's him and he stayed there (and if he was born in Canada), perhaps his naturalization application will be in that county, too. Good luck.